blamblog banner

           
  Wednesday, September 24, 2008

Division 101


Harris via Harper Valley.

It's become pretty clear that Harper's arts cuts are a divide & conquer strategy in the ol' Mike Harris style. And it works by playing to common prejudices, even if reality is somewhat different:

"I think when ordinary working people come home, turn on the TV and see a gala of a bunch of people at, you know, a rich gala all subsidized by taxpayers claiming their subsidies aren't high enough, when they know those subsidies have actually gone up -- I'm not sure that's something that resonates with ordinary people,"

See? There are two types of people in the world: "ordinary" people and "rich" artist "elites". The "elites" are blowing taxpayer money on galas and the "ordinary" people need someone like Harper to put a stop to it. Kinsella spotted it:

Did they kick at this hornet's nest deliberately, or did they merely trip on it? The next few days will tell. At the risk of sounding like a Philistine, I can assure you that if the denizens of Deepest Annex leave their million-dollar homes and take to the airwaves to bray and shriek about the cuts, and liken them to an apocalypse and whatnot, they will lose Middle Canada -- and play right into Stephen Harper's hands. If, however, the artistic community plays it smart -- by cooling the rhetoric, speaking in French, and detailing the significant economic benefits of a thriving culture -- they might just win, and thereby do some serious damage to the Conservatives' lusted-after majority. Art is the triumph over chaos -- but can it triumph over politics?

To further inflame the issue, the conservatives cut funding quietly by redirecting funds through Canadian Heritage (the Globe crunched the numbers and exposed this last weekend) so that they could accuse the arts community of getting upset over nothing, making them seem even more like spoiled brats in the eyes of so-called "ordinary" people.

Here's a test you can perform yourself when the weekend papers come out (or Toronto Life or whatever): look up the society pages and check out the pictures from any recent galas. Do you see lots of artists or do you see rich people who aren't artists? If you're unsure of who's who, the artists are the awkward minority, looking out of place in the corner because they don't often get out of their basement studios to attend galas in their Value Village sneakers. And note how many of the wealthy people in those photos are Tories (for example: William Thorsell? Tory.).

The fact of the matter is, almost everybody who works in the arts in Canada is really, really poor. I'm sure there's someone, somewhere who is swaddled in government cash for life ... but I've never met them. Even the few who make a decent living could make far more money doing other things. I split my work between corporate projects and arts projects and the budgets of mundane, low-level corporate projects (ones that, when completed, get tossed out because the VP gets shuffled) would be viewed by most people in the arts as vast mountains of wealth.

I think there are people who wish there was an artistic elite because it sounds very romantic. Galen Weston Jr. -- son of a billionaire businessman, not an artist -- created the Spoke Club to help foster such a thing. But most of the people I've known who work in the arts are ordinary people who inhabit their communities ... they're not separate from other people. Look at some "big" names as examples: Alice Munroe lives in Clinton, not Rosedale. Timothy Findley lived outside of Cannington. Colm Feore lives in Stratford. Greg Curnoe not only lived in scrappy London, the region consumed his work.

Harper's division strategy also works because people who work in the arts don't agree with one another on how the arts should be funded (for example, lots of people think money spent on that mega-fest, Luminato, would be better spent directly supporting artists). So, the issue also gets people within the arts sniping at each other. It worked the same when when Harris went after the teachers. Everybody against everybody.

As a strategy, it's a cynical play on people's emotions ... but the Harris gang made it work for them and Harper's having luck with it so far.
 

10:22 AM , # , |


   

design portfoliodesign portfoliodesign portfolio
design portfolio

Contact
info[at]brettlamb[dot]com


My Cartoon Archives
HAPPY CREATURE
MS. JOHNSON
ED LOCKE

Regular reads
Accordion Guy
Bill Doskoch
Daily Dose
Davezilla
Tony Pierce
Warren Kinsella

News
BlogTO
boingboing
Cursor
DIGG
Dork Shelf
Drawn!
FoodForethought
Fleshbot
Garlicster
Global Nerdy
MetaFilter
Mondoville
The Oil Drum
Reddit
The Register
Slashdot
Space.com
Spacing Wire
Torontoist
Treehugger
ZDNet

Arts & comics
Children of the Atom
Chromewaves
Comic Strip
Corrigan
DeadThingsonSticks
Dinosaur Comics
Hollywood North Report
Maakies
MacKay
Sally McKay
Secret Lair
Toronto Comic Jam
Zoilus

Audio
The Bugle
Coverville
Radio Clash
Ramdom Thoughts

Video
Channel101

Toronto blogs
Circadian Shift
Consolation Champs
Crazy Biker Chick
Day in the Life
Dead Robot
Easternblot
estrojenn
Exhausticated
Free Clara
JB Warehouse & EmporiumLiz Vang
Luminescent
Marmalade
Merv
Naked KnitGirl
Photojunkie
Pony
Pshaw
Raymi the Minx
Robot Johnny
Searching for Tao
Secret Storm
Squiddity
TBIT

Canadian blogs
Simple Spendor
Sooey
Confessions of a Monkey
Dust My Broom
Grrl Meets World
Ian King
James Bow
Simple Spendor
Sooey
View from up here

USA blogs
Cityrag
democraticSPACE
Dooce
Explananda
Fred the Blog
Jett Superior
Maakies
MegaBeth
Panopticist
Yoon Choi

Oz blogs
Brett Lamb: OZ
Little Lioness
Penguin Says Yes

UK
B3TA
Rathergood

View My Portfolio

  Brett Lamb

Create Your Badge

www.flickr.com
blamb's items Go to blamb's photostream

A R C H I V E S

2009
JANUARY

FEBRUARY

MARCH

APRIL

MAY

JUNE

JULY

AUGUST

SEPTEMBER

OCTOBER

NOVEMBER

DECEMBER

2008
JANUARY
FEBRUARY
MARCH
APRIL
MAY
JUNE
JULY
AUGUST
SEPTEMBER
OCTOBER
NOVEMBER
DECEMBER


2007
JANUARY
FEBRUARY
MARCH
APRIL
MAY
JUNE
JULY
AUGUST
SEPTEMBER
OCTOBER
NOVEMBER
DECEMBER


2006
JANUARY - 1
JANUARY - 2
FEBRUARY
MARCH
APRIL
MAY
JUNE
JULY
AUGUST
SEPTEMBER
OCTOBER
NOVEMBER
DECEMBER
APRIL
MAY
JUNE
JULY
AUGUST

2005
JANUARY
FEBRUARY
MARCH
APRIL
MAY
JUNE
JULY
AUGUST
SEPTEMBER
OCTOBER
NOVEMBER
DECEMBER

2004
MAY
JUNE
JULY
AUGUST
SEPTEMBER
OCTOBER
NOVEMBER
DECEMBER

[ 2003 ] [ 2002 ]

 
       
View My Stats